Tenant screening is the most critical process for protecting your single-family home investment in the Central Valley, but it is also the highest-risk activity for triggering a fair housing complaint. The law requires you to treat all applicants equally and base your decision on objective, financial, and behavioral factors—never on protected characteristics. The goal is to establish a legal, documented, and consistent screening process.
Step 1: Define and Publish Objective Screening Criteria
Before you list your property, you must create a clear, written set of rental criteria that you will apply to every single applicant. This consistency is your number one legal defense.
Legally Safe Criteria (Objective):
Income-to-Rent Ratio: Require verifiable income of, for example, 2.5 to 3 times the monthly rent.
Minimum Credit Score: Set a non-discriminatory minimum score (e.g., 620).
Rental History: Require positive references and no prior evictions (Unlawful Detainers).
Background Check: Define standards for relevant criminal convictions (must be narrowly tailored—see the Fair Housing article).
The Crucial Income Rule (Source of Income): In California, you cannot disqualify an applicant simply because a portion of their income comes from a source like a Section 8 housing voucher, veteran's benefits, or Social Security. You must apply the same income-to-rent ratio to the legally protected source of income as you would to wage income.
Publishing the Criteria: Post your criteria on your rental listing, application form, and website. Applicants should know exactly what they need to qualify before they apply.
Step 2: Apply the Rules Consistently (The Litmus Test)
Consistency is the law’s measuring stick. Any deviation from your written policy for a single applicant can be used as evidence of discrimination if that applicant belongs to a protected class and is denied.
Uniform Application: Every applicant must use the same application form and pay the same screening fee (which is capped by California law and must be used for actual costs).
Same Checks: Run the exact same reports (credit, criminal, eviction, income verification) on every single adult applicant.
No "Gut" Decisions: Do not accept or deny a promising or "unsettling" applicant based on a personal feeling or appearance. You must complete the full screening process, and the final decision must be justifiable by a failure to meet one or more of your written, objective criteria.
Step 3: What You Must AVOID in the Central Valley
These questions, comments, or policies are illegal because they inquire about or have a discriminatory impact on protected classes:
| Protected Class | Illegal Action/Question to Avoid |
| Familial Status | Asking if they have children, how old their children are, or setting an arbitrary limit on the number of children. |
| Disability | Asking if an applicant has a disability, asking for medical records, or asking for the nature or severity of a disability. |
| Race/National Origin | Asking where an applicant was born or their primary language (unless needed to provide services). |
| Source of Income | Refusing to accept Section 8 or other housing assistance solely because it is a voucher. |
| Criminal History | Automatically denying anyone with any criminal record. Must be narrowly tailored (e.g., focusing on recent, severe, violent, or property-related felony convictions). |
Step 4: Document Everything and Provide Adverse Action Notices
Documentation is your legal protection. For every denied applicant, you must retain the following records for at least three years:
The completed application.
Your written screening criteria.
The screening reports (credit, eviction, background check).
A documented note showing which specific criterion they failed to meet (e.g., "Income was 1.5x rent, below 2.5x minimum").
Adverse Action Notice: If you deny an applicant based on information in a consumer report (like a credit or background check), you must send them an "Adverse Action Notice." This notice must include:
The name, address, and contact information of the consumer reporting agency (CRA) that provided the report.
A statement that the CRA did not make the decision to deny and cannot explain why it was denied.
Notice of the applicant's right to obtain a free copy of the report from the CRA within 60 days and their right to dispute the accuracy of the report.
By implementing this rigid, documented, and objective four-step process, Central Valley property managers can confidently select the highest quality tenants for their single-family homes while remaining legally insulated from fair housing claims.
Site Links