For single-family home landlords in the Central Valley, the desire to increase security through video surveillance is understandable. Cameras can deter crime and protect your investment. However, when placing security cameras on a rental property, you enter a complicated legal area that intersects with tenant privacy rights. Compliance in cities like Modesto, Stockton, and Bakersfield is about finding a lawful balance between security and the tenant's reasonable expectation of privacy.
The Guiding Principle: Reasonable Expectation of Privacy
California law, particularly the Penal Code, makes a critical distinction that dictates where you can and cannot place cameras: the tenant’s reasonable expectation of privacy.
Where Cameras are Permitted (Generally):
Cameras are generally lawful in areas where the expectation of privacy is naturally low or non-existent, and where the cameras are visible:
Exterior Public-Facing Areas: Driveways, walkways leading up to the front door, the front porch, and areas overlooking a public street.
Backyards/Patios (Commonly Debated): For a single-family home, the private backyard or exclusive-use patio is generally considered part of the leased premises where the tenant does have a reasonable expectation of privacy. It is highly advisable to avoid placing cameras that directly record private, exclusive-use areas of a single-family home's yard or patio without the tenant's explicit, written consent in the lease. If the camera must be there for security, it should be angled to capture common access points only.
Where Cameras are Strictly Prohibited:
Cameras are illegal in any area where a person has a heightened or reasonable expectation of privacy:
Inside the Rental Unit: This is an absolute prohibition. Placing a camera inside the living space of the single-family home, including the garage, is a serious violation of privacy.
Areas That Peer into the Interior: Cameras positioned outside that are aimed to look directly through a window or doorway into the living space.
Audio Recording: The Two-Party Consent Law
A crucial element to remember in California is the Two-Party Consent Law for recording conversations (California Penal Code $\S 632$). This means that all parties to a confidential communication must consent to being recorded.
Video-Only is Best: Most security camera systems should be set to record video only. If your cameras are capable of capturing audio, and they record a conversation where one of the parties had a reasonable expectation that the conversation was private, you may be violating the law.
Confidential Communication: An expectation of privacy exists when the communication is carried on "in circumstances as may reasonably indicate that the parties to such communication desire it to be confined to the parties thereto." Recording casual conversations, even in a backyard, can cross a legal line.
Best Practices for Single-Family Home Landlords
To ensure full compliance and avoid costly legal disputes in the Central Valley, follow these steps:
Written Disclosure is Mandatory: You must disclose the existence and placement of all exterior security cameras in the lease agreement or an addendum. Transparency is your best defense. This is especially important if the tenant is responsible for managing the system.
Focus on Common Access Points: Limit camera placement to the front entrance, driveway, and potentially the gate leading to the backyard, ensuring the field of view does not intrude upon the private living space.
Visible Placement: All cameras should be visible and not hidden. Hidden or “nanny-cams” placed by the landlord are considered a strong violation of privacy.
No Interior Monitoring: Absolutely no cameras are allowed inside the single-family home while it is being rented. Even if the tenant installs one, it is their responsibility, not the landlord’s.
Develop a Data Policy: Establish clear guidelines for how the footage is stored, how long it is kept, and who has access to it. Footage should only be viewed when necessary (e.g., in response to an incident or police request).
By strictly adhering to the "no reasonable expectation of privacy" standard, disabling audio recording, and ensuring complete transparency with your tenants, Central Valley landlords can legally utilize security camera technology to protect their investment without infringing on their tenant's rights.
Site Links